Skip to main content
Version: v20

Null and Undefined

Null and Undefined are data types that handle cases where the value of an expression is not known.


Null is a special data type with only one possible value: null. This value is returned by an expression that does not contain any value. Trying to read a property of a null value returns an error.

In the 4D language and for object field attributes, null values are managed through the Null function. This function can be used with the following expressions for setting or comparing the null value:

  • object attributes
  • collection elements
  • variables of the object, collection, pointer, picture, or variant type (see also Null as default value.


Undefined is not actually a data type. It denotes a variable that has not yet been defined. Evaluating an object property can also produce an undefined value. Reading a property of an undefined value returns undefined.

A variant variable has undefined as default value.

A field cannot be undefined (the Undefined command always returns False for a field).

Typically when trying to read or assign undefined expressions, 4D will generate errors, except in the following cases:

  • Assigning an undefined value to variables (except arrays) has the same effect as calling CLEAR VARIABLE with them:
     var $o : Object
var $val : Integer
$val:=10 //$val=10
$val:=$o.a //$o.a is undefined (no error), and assigning this value clears the variable
  • Assigning an undefined value to an existing object property reinitializes or clears its value, depending on its type:
    • Object, collection, pointer: Null
    • Picture: Empty picture
    • Boolean: False
    • String: ""
    • Number: 0
    • Date: !00-00-00! if "Use date type instead of ISO date format in objects" setting is enabled, otherwise ""
    • Time: 0 (number of ms)
    • Undefined, Null: no change
     var $o : Object
$o:=New object("a";2)
$o.a:=$o.b //$o.a=0
  • Assigning an undefined value to a non existing object property does nothing.

  • An undefined value passed as parameter to a project method is automatically converted to 0 or "" according to the declared parameter type.

     var $o : Object
mymethod($o.a) //pass an undefined parameter

//In mymethod method
#Declare ($myText : Text) //parameter type is text
// $myText contains ""
  • A condition expression is automatically converted to false when evaluating to undefined with the If and Case of keywords:
     var $o : Object
If($o.a) // false
End if
Case of
:($o.a) // false
End case

When expressions of a given type are expected in your 4D code, you can make sure they have the correct type even when evaluated to undefined by surrounding them with the appropriate 4D cast command: String, Num, Date, Time, Bool. These commands return an empty value of the specified type when the expression evaluates to undefined. For example:

 $myString:=Lowercase(String($o.a.b)) //make sure you get a string value even if undefined
//to avoid errors in the code

Null operators

EqualityNull = NullBooleana.nullProp = b.nullPropTrue
Null = UndefinedBooleana.nullProp = b.undefinedPropTrue
Null = scalar valueBooleana.nullProp = 42False
InequalityNull # NullBooleana.nullProp # b.nullPropFalse
Null # UndefinedBooleana.nullProp # b.undefinedPropFalse
Null # scalar valueBooleana.nullProp # 42True

scalar values are values of type string, Date, Time, Boolean, number, or Blob. When declared, their default value is neither undefined nor null. Other types (Pointer, Picture, Object, Collection) have undefined or null default value. Ex:

var $object : Object
var $text : Text

//$object = null
//$text = ""

Comparisons with Greater than (>), Less than (<), Greater than or equal to (>=), and Less than or equal to (<=) operators are not supported with Null values and return an error.

Undefined operators

EqualityUndefined = UndefinedBooleana.undefinedProp = b.undefinedPropTrue
Undefined = NullBooleana.undefinedProp = c.nullPropTrue
Undefined = other valuesBooleana.undefinedProp = 42False
InequalityUndefined # UndefinedBooleana.undefinedProp # b.undefinedPropFalse
Undefined # NullBooleana.undefinedProp # b.nullPropFalse
Undefined # other valuesBooleana.undefinedProp # 42True
Greater thanUndefined > string, Date, Time, Boolean, numberBooleana.undefinedProp > "abc"False
Less thanUndefined < string, Date, Time, Boolean, numberBooleana.undefinedProp < "abc"False
Greater than or equal toUndefined >= string, Date, Time, Boolean, numberBooleana.undefinedProp >= "abc"False
Less than or equal toUndefined <= string, Date, Time, Boolean, numberBooleana.undefinedProp <= "abc"False

other values are expressions of any type with a value neither Undefined nor Null.


Comparisons of Undefined values with Pointer, Picture, Blob, Object, Collection, Undefined or Null values using Greater than (>), Less than (<), Greater than or equal to (>=), and Less than or equal to (<=) operators are not supported and return an error.


Here are the different results of the Undefined command as well as the Null command with object properties, depending on the context:

var $vEmp : Object
var $result : Boolean
$vEmp:=New object


$result:=Undefined($ //False
$result:=($ //False

$result:=Undefined($vEmp.children) //False
$result:=($vEmp.children=Null) //True

$result:=Undefined($vEmp.parent) //True
$result:=($vEmp.parent=Null) //True

Examples of comparison results with undefined and null values:

var $result : Boolean
var $vObj : Object
var $vVar : Variant

$vObj:=New object
//note that $vVar is not assigned

$result:=($vObj.undefined=42) //False
$result:=($vObj.undefined=$vObj.null) //True
$result:=($vObj.undefined=$vVar) //True

$result:=($vObj.undefined#$vObj.null) //False
$result:=($vObj.undefined#42) //True
$result:=($vObj.undefined#$vVar) //False

$result:=($vObj.undefined>"hello") //False
$result:=($vObj.undefined>$vVar) //Error
$result:=($vObj.undefined>$vObj.null) //Error
$result:=($vVar < 42) //False